"The Testimony of Jesus": One Phrase, Two Adventist Emphases

1. Issue framed

Revelation 12:17 describes the dragon going to war against "the rest of her offspring." It says they are "those who keep God's commands and hold fast their testimony about Jesus" (NIV). Other translations put the last words as "have the testimony of Jesus Christ" (KJV).

That small phrase carries weight in Adventist teaching. Is it a sign that points to a prophet among God's end-time people? Or is its main focus on Jesus' own witness to who God is?

This examination looks only at that phrase. A companion article looks at the separate question of who the remnant is.

2. Documented positions in view

The voted belief. Fundamental Belief 18, "The Gift of Prophecy," says that this gift "is an identifying mark of the remnant church." It also says "we believe it was manifested in the ministry of Ellen G. White." It lists Revelation 12:17, 19:10, and 22:8–9 among its texts. The writings, it adds, "make clear that the Bible is the standard by which all teaching and experience must be tested."

Emphasis A: the prophetic gift as the mark. Gerhard Pfandl is a retired associate director of the church's Biblical Research Institute. In "The testimony of Jesus" in Ministry (October 2016), he reads the phrase as the witness Jesus Himself gives through His prophets. He concludes that "the visible remnant church" has two marks: keeping God's commandments, and having "the Spirit of prophecy or the prophetic gift."

Emphasis B: the witness Jesus gave about God. Sigve K. Tonstad wrote "Timeout: After the Thousand Years" in Spectrum (March 23, 2019). He also reads the phrase as testimony from Jesus. But he writes that the text "is not about our witness to Jesus or a prescient technical term for an inspired writer in the nineteenth century." Instead, "it speaks of the constancy of God that was demonstrated in the costly testimony of Jesus."

A mediating study. Leonard Valwen Tan of Asia-Pacific International University wrote "The Testimony of Jesus in Revelation 12:17" in Journal Koinonia (June 2026). He argues the phrase "encompasses both divine revelation and faithful witness." He favors testimony that comes from Christ but says it "simultaneously includes the responsive witness of believers." He sees Ellen White's ministry as "a historical manifestation of the biblical gift of prophecy."

All three are individual studies, not voted statements.

3. Scriptural arguments attributed and compared

Revelation 19:10 and 22:9. Pfandl's main argument links two verses, which he quotes in the RSV. In 19:10 the angel calls himself a fellow servant of those who "hold the testimony of Jesus," and adds that this testimony "is the spirit of prophecy." In 22:9, in the same setting, the brethren are simply called "prophets." Pfandl concludes that the spirit of prophecy belongs to "those who have been called by God to be prophets," not to every believer.

The word "have." Pfandl also notes that the verb in 12:17 means "to have" and points to something possessed. If John meant believers' witness about Jesus, he says, John would have written that they "testify about Jesus."

The pattern across the book. Tonstad points to a set of paired phrases in Revelation 1:2, 1:9, 12:17, 14:12, and 20:4. In each, God's word or commands stand beside the testimony or faithfulness of Jesus. He reads them as a refrain: "God has been explained in the world through the witness of Jesus." He ties that witness to the Lamb of Revelation 5:6, which he renders as "killed with violence."

Holding both together. Tan accepts the link to 19:10. But he notes that some scholars warn against putting too much weight on that one verse. He suggests that testimony "flows from divine disclosure to human witness."

4. Historical and teaching context

Ángel Manuel Rodríguez, a retired Biblical Research Institute scholar, makes a related claim in a footnote to his public article "The Remnant and the Adventist Church". He writes that Ellen White "never interprets the manifestation of the gift of prophecy in her life as a fulfillment of Rev 12:17." He adds that she did not deny that the phrase includes her gift. He supports this with his own unpublished 1998 paper. We relied only on the public article and haven’t seen that paper.

Tonstad, for his part, is responding to a quoted Sabbath School lesson that links the verse to Ellen White's ministry. He suggests Adventists "scale back our claims about ourselves." He adds that no key Adventist affirmation "will suffer" if they do.

5. Agreements and disagreements

Agreement. All three writers say the phrase means testimony that comes from Jesus. None reads it as merely believers talking about Jesus. Pfandl and Tan both see Ellen White's ministry as a manifestation of the prophetic gift. Tonstad's column challenges applying Revelation 12:17 to that gift. It does not settle what all his views on the gift are.

Difference. The real difference is about application. Pfandl reads 12:17 as a mark that identifies the Adventist church through its prophetic gift. Tonstad reads the verse as centered on Jesus' own revealing of God, and warns against reading the church into it. Tan holds the two together.

These are partly compatible emphases. They are not a clean split over grammar.

6. Implications and uncertainties

How the phrase is read affects how Adventists explain their identity to others. It can be framed as "we have the prophet," or as "we hold to what Jesus revealed." Belief 18 itself joins the gift to the remnant and keeps the Bible as the test of all teaching.

Rodríguez's claim about Ellen White's own usage is his, made in a footnote.

Sources (5)

• Fundamental Beliefs (Belief 18) — Official
• Gerhard Pfandl, "The testimony of Jesus," Ministry, October 2016 — Official
• Sigve K. Tonstad, "Timeout: After the Thousand Years," Spectrum, March 23, 2019 — Independent Progressive
• Leonard Valwen Tan, "The Testimony of Jesus in Revelation 12:17," Journal Koinonia, June 2026 — Global & Regional
• Ángel Manuel Rodríguez, "The Remnant and the Adventist Church," Biblical Research Institute — Official

Source categories describe type only, not reliability. About our source categories.

Cite this

"The Testimony of Jesus": One Phrase, Two Adventist Emphases. Puls Strom, Nov 6, 2026. https://pulsstrom.com/c/cf4d6e

Copy linkCopy citation

Spotted an error? Report it. Substantive corrections are noted at the top of the piece and listed on the corrections page.